We recently got married and when the groomsmen decorated our vehicle they put shoe polish on our black fender wells and we can't get it off! We've tried WD-40, high pressure wash, & scrubbing.
We just got married this weekend so it's only be 2 days now. I'll have to try the Magic Eraser. THANKS
It isn't on the paint but on the black fender wells that goes over the truck tires and front bumper. My friend owns a body shop and he is the one who suggested the WD 40 and said that he would have to probably replace them if that didn't work. It's about $2000 worth of damage.

Shoe polish is only supposed to be used on glass. You are going to have to get your car re-painted if they put it on the fenders!